Wise Co. Coal DEQ Hearing…

Live from Dominion Boulevard at the beautiful Marriott in Glenn Allen, Virginia, here is your live blog on the last Department of Environmental Quality hearing for Dominion’s proposed Wise County coal fired power plant…

(6:15pm)First and foremost, seriously, this hearing is on Dominion Blvd. I think that is because we are in close proximity to a Dominion office, or it is because Dominion owns this road… one or the other… Either way, the irony that an environmental hearing is taking place on Dominion Blvd is not lost on this attendee.

There are about 300 people here, many of whom oppose the plant. For the first time in the series of hearings on the Wise Co. plant, opponents were one of the first ones to sign up to testify. At other hearings, Dominion’s supporters (which include employees…) testified for up to two hours before any opponents got a chance to speak. This is due in large part to the fact that the actual sign up time posted by the DEQ is often very different than the posted sign up time. Today, sign up was scheduled to begin at 4:45pm. The first sign up sheet was posted at 3:00pm. But thankfully, we learned our lesson and got we were staked out at the hearing location starting at 9:30am this morning in preparation for this predictable twist.

Josh Tulkin was the first opponent to testify today. His testimony was highlighted when he asked all the opponents of the plant at the hearing to stand up. Half the room stood up, and DEQ Chairman immediately said, “Mr. Tulkin, you are out of order!” To which Mr. Tulkin coyly replied, “I respectfully withdraw my request.”

Other testimony include a statement from Gerald E. Connolly, the Chairman of the Fairfax County Board, in which he respectfully asked Dominion to explore alternatives to the coal plant that would harm the air quality in Fairfax and totally offset all the progress that counties like Fairfax have made through local initiatives to reduce carbon dioxide emissions.

Oh, and a side note, I would like to thank Dominion for feeding me.

(7:36pm) About half the people here have left. The break was festive and the students seemed have an an expectational time. I get the feeling that the plant opponents of the plant now far outnumber the proponents… now the party can really begin.

The best quote of the night so far came from one JMU student (I already forgot his name) who stepped up to the microphone and said, “My name is Joe Smith, and I am not a former employee of Dominion…” We all laughed…

(7:48pm) A man just walked up to me as I was sitting and told me how there is, “no Mountain Top removal in the state of Virginia.” Seriously. He said that, and I don’t think he was joking. I respectfully informed him that he was mistaken and that I could show him pictures taken from a tour of the Mountains of Wise County that I took last week. The Bristol-Herald Courier also took the same tour… I guess what we saw doesn’t exist…

FYI, 25% of Wise County’s total land area has already been leveled due to mountain top removal.

(7:55pm) Richmond City Councilman Marty Jewell just testified. He is very concerned about global warming and how the proposed power plant would effect Richmond’s air quality.

“I like cream in my coffee, not sludge!” — Councilman Jewell, in reference to mountain top removal mining.

New Coal in Wise Will Affect Richmond

Richmond City Councilmen Hilbert and Jewell have introduced the Wise County Resolution, 2008-R13. This resolution is a strong statement of opposition to the proposed coal-fired power plant in Wise County, Virginia. So why is the City of Richmond weighing in on an issue for Wise County? On the surface it may seem that they’re just butting in but this plant is very much the business of Richmond and its citizens.

This plant is a bad investment and every Richmonder with an electric bill will have to pay for it. Dominion will pass all the costs of the plant onto the ratepayers of Virginia. Those costs include $1.8 billion to build the plant, 14% profit for Dominion, and also the cost of controlling carbon emissions which may reach $100 million each year. That means quite a lot of money out of our pockets. I don’t want any of my money funding new coal but Dominion isn’t giving me the ability to choose clean energy. If ratepayers must pay for new energy generation why can we not have a say in how it is generated? Across the country more and more people are realizing that coal simply costs too much. According to the US Department of Energy, $1.8 billion is too much to pay for a coal-fired power plant. The DOE recently pulled support for a proposed plant in Illinois based on cost. Just a few days ago three of the largest financial supporters of new coal reassessed the risks and found them to be too high. Citigroup Inc., J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. and Morgan Stanley have realized that carbon control legislation is inevitable, which will make coal far more costly. As a result they will encourage utilities to invest in energy-efficiency and renewable energy as alternatives to new coal. Asking Dominion to invest in efficiency, conservation, and renewables is exactly what this resolution does.

Where our energy comes from and the effects of its production is most certainly our business. The City of Richmond is powered by coal. That coal is supplied by the coalfields of southwest Virginia. The coal that powers my home comes from a strip mine site in Tazewell Virginia. When I turn on the lights in my house I am inadvertently contributing to mountaintop removal mining. The proposed power plant in Wise County will not be used to supply power to southwest Virginia. That power will enter the grid and be used to power the growing urban areas of NOVA, Richmond, and Tidewater. It is being built specifically to supply power to places like Richmond. At the recent State Corporation Commission hearing on the Wise County plant held in Richmond life-long Wise County resident Frank Taylor spoke of the sacrifices by the people of the coalfields for our energy needs. “Haven’t we sacrificed enough to provide power to our country? The thousands of men who have lost their lives in the mines, the tens of thousands who have black lung and the great amount of the land itself stripped away. Isn’t that enough? And now they want us to give up the clean air that we and our children breathe? Shame.” We certainly have the right to make a statement regarding where our power comes from and the damage it does.

This resolution has already been passed in Arlington, Albemarle, Charlottesville, and Blacksburg. It is now being discussed in Fairfax County. The people of Richmond also have a right to ask Dominion to invest in energy efficiency and conservation that will save us all money and keep us from unwillingly encouraging the destruction of Wise County. No new coal in my name. No new coal funded by my wallet.

VA SCC Hears Case on Wise County Coal Plant

scc.gif

I went and observed the first day of a 4-plus day evidentiary hearing at the Virginia State Corporation Commission yesterday. The hearing is set up like an actual trial, with Dominion’s Wise County coal plant construction permit at the heart of the case. The first day consisted mainly of two of Dominion’s Senior Vice-Presidents. They were the first of Dominion’s witnesses that submitted direct testimony. The evidentiary hearing is held so that each side of the case (Dominion as the applicant and Southern Environmental Law Center representing App Voices, Sierra Club, SAMS and CCAN as one of a few of the respondents) to cross-examine each parties expert witnesses.

Continue reading

Rep Moran and Hundreds Say No To Coal!

Hundreds of Northern Virginians gathered at a town hall meeting last night to discuss the antiquated use of coal in Virginia and the opportunities provided by a clean energy future. The public forum, which drew an estimated 200 people, focused on the connection between two coal-fired power plants in Virginia — the Mirant Plant in Alexandria and the proposed Dominion power plant in Wise County — and mountaintop removal coal mining.

Rep Moran“Burning fossil fuels is the single largest source of greenhouse gas emissions, and burning coal is about the worst thing we can do,” said Congressman Jim Moran. “With 50 percent of our electricity generated by coal-fired power plants, it will take a realistic but focused and determined effort to reduce greenhouse emissions from coal-fired plants and increase the use of cleaner, alternative sources of energy.”

At a time when states from Kansas to Texas are rejecting permits to build new coal plants, speakers tonight argued that building a new coal-fired power plant, as Dominion Virginia Power is proposing to do in SW Virginia, would put Virginia behind the curve when it comes to investing in renewable energy.

“We are all Virginians, even those in southwest Virginia, said Kathy Selvage, a Wise County resident who spoke at the forum. “The proposed Wise County plant will spew 25 million pounds of pollutants into our air each year. While Gov. Kaine and Dominion tell us that this plant will be good for the economy, they have not taken into account the increased need for health care, or those components that are truly priceless like the preservation of the air we breathe, the water we drink, or the fish we eat.”
Continue reading

Dominion Power's Dirty Plans for Virginia

The Washington Post

By Mike Tidwell

Fact: Virginia gets less than 1 percent of its electricity from “green” sources such as the wind or the sun. Fact: Virginia ranks 38th among U.S. states in energy efficiency. Fact: Climate change is real, and fossil fuel substitutes are needed, according to President Bush’s State of the Union address last year. So how would Dominion Virginia Power respond to these facts?

Continue reading

Wise County Air Pollution Control Board Hearing, Alexandria, VA

Where are you NoVa? I am currently sitting here at the at the lovely Holiday Inn on Eisenhower Ave, at a public Air Pollution Control Board hearing — one of the first of these types of hearings — and it is me, Kayti from the Sierra Club, Ernie from NOTICe, a few other activists and a room full of Dominion suits. The front row is literally comprised solely of Dominion “experts” who are working the podium, seemingly in a rotation, in an effort to deflect criticism and offer non-answers to serious questions. We have to be outnumbered… or at least that is the feeling that I am getting…

Dominion is talking the talk about how the proposed Wise County CFB coal fired power plant is going to be the best thing since sliced bread — how they their plant can use waste coal and biomass like wood-chips, how their plant will have lower SOx and NOx emissions than an IGCC coal plant. Yes, there are lots of wonky terms at a hearing like this (PSM, public health, environment, endanger), that not everyone will understand, but the feeling of deceit is palpable and accessible to everyone in attendance.

For example:

The presentation from Dominion to the Board included a large section about CCS, carbon capture and sequestration, and how compatible the Wise County plant may be, if the technology one day becomes available at a cost-effective price, with CCS and how that should mean that Virginians should not worry about this plant’s estimated 5.4 million tons of annual CO2 emissions. When asked when we could expect the plant to start to turn CCS compatibility into CCS reality, the Dominion speaker said, “decades.” Continue reading

Virginia's Citizen's Lobby Day

We attended the Virginia Conservation Network-Va. League of Conservation Voters-Va. Garden Club training, Legislative Lobby Day 2008. The hall was crowded; about 300 people with a variety of conservation interests from all over the state attended, including half a dozen of our friends from up the road at the Williamsburg CAN.

(BTW, look beyond the roses before you pooh-pooh the Va. Garden Clubs; they are formidable–an extremely large, active, effective, and well-connected conservation group who are take quite seriously by the General Assembly.)

During the day we met with six Hampton Roads legislators or their legislative assistants during the day to express our support for many pending acts:(a complete list can be found on our site http://www.twcan.org/docs.cfm, ga2008.pdf ) IMG_0011

  • SB 446 Clean Energy Future Act; the Chesapeake Climate Action Network’s flagship bill bringing clean energy, clean jobs training and clean jobs to Virginia
  • HB 650 Department of Environmental Quality; maintaining the 62-year history and authority of Virginia’s Citizens Boards.
  • SB 625 Bipartisan Redistricting Commission; to stop the endless political gerrymandering of district lines and inserting some rational guidelines into the process
  • SB 320 to end covenants restricting solar energy collection devices
  • HB 153 Solar water heating system pay-as-you-save pilot program, to make solar hot water more affordable for more people.

Continue reading

Virginia – Who REALLY cares about Global Warming?

As of today, I have nine names for you. Nine champions for the environment. Nine brave legislatures have already co-patroned the Clean Energy Future Act, Senator Chap Petersen’s bold plan for Virginia.

CO-PATRONS OF SB446, The Clean Energy Future Act
* Senators Chap Petersen, Roscoe Reynolds, and Patsy Ticer
* Delegates Adam Ebbin, David Englin, David Poisson, Joe Bouchard, David Toscano, Margaret Vanderhyde

Is your legislator one of them? If not, ask your legislator to co-patron the Clean Energy Future Act.

Now, this ain’t bad for one day of grueling work walking the capitol. I enjoyed it. But it would be a lot more fun if I had company. So come on down and join the Chesapeake Climate Action Network and VCN for Clean Energy Lobby Day. Its this Monday, January 21st. Yes, I know its MLK day – what better way to celebrate you day off them to join with other concerned citizens to try to save the climate. Register today.

Have any more updates on this great bill? Write to josh[at]chesapeakeclimate.org. The climate needs all the help it can get, and so do we.

BWT – This bill will go through the Commerce and Labor Committee in the Senate. None of them are currently co-sponsors. If you know them, show them some love.

Mark Herring, Don McEachin, Chuck Colgan, John Edwards, Yvonne Miller, Toddy Puller , Phil Puckett, Frank Wagner, John C. Watkins, Tommy Norment, William Wampler, Steve Newman, Walter Stosch, Ken Stolle.

SCC Hears Virginians Say No to Coal!

Boy: Global Warming Starts Here

On January 8th, hundreds of people from all over the state descended upon Richmond to have their voices heard by the State Corporation Commission on the issue of whether to build another coal fired power plant in Wise County. By our count, there were over 300 dissenters at the hearing (a number so large that we required a spillover courtroom to hold us all), 177 of which were registered to testify. These numbers are in addition to the 815 people who submitted written testimony to the SCC by the December deadline. The testimony was strong, and the message was clear: we don’t want coal!

Lawyers who have been working with the SCC for upwards to 30 years have said that they have never seen anything like the public turnout that the Wise County plant is receiving.

But this is more than just the sheer numbers; this is about who was there, where they were from, and how they got there.

Continue reading